Daily Archives: August 14, 2008

Measuring the quality of education not as simple as it seems – Letters – Opinion

Measuring the quality of education not as simple as it seems writes Greg Whitby, Executive director of schools, Catholic diocese of Parramatta. How true that is! Mind you I wonder a little at his opening paragraph, though I can see why he has done it. Can’t help wondering who the UNprofessional educators might be though… Perhaps “teachers” is enough?

Professional educators would welcome Julia Gillard’s assertion that teaching excellence should be identified and rewarded, and that high standards be expected of all students (“Tell-all report cards to compare schools“, August 12). We all want better schools.

However, the strategies for improving education require careful scrutiny. Comprehensive and valid data is a necessary basis for any improvement strategy. However, great care must be taken in interpreting and applying this data if it is expected to guide the educational agenda and determine resource levels.

A test-driven curriculum would undoubtedly distort educational programs; and general comparisons of schools, not based on a thorough understanding of the complexities of learning and teaching, would simply mislead and distract the public.

Even comparisons of schools in similar environments, and with similar problems, may not be helpful unless based on a deeply informed understanding of the specific context, culture and rate of improvement of the schools concerned.

When governments around the world have adopted quick and simple solutions to complex educational problems, they have usually got it wrong and seem determined to continue doing so.

It would be so much easier if schools were factories, created to produce easily measured, standardised products. But they are not. They are full of vibrant, growing, learning human beings, each with individual needs, styles, natural abilities and background experiences.

We have known for well over two decades now that the key to improving students’ learning is a combination of good teachers using relevant methods. We would be better served by helping teachers to continuously improve the effectiveness of their teaching, rather than focusing on narrow measures of some aspects of student achievement that don’t show the whole picture.

The world of learning is delightfully complex. We need to be careful we do not confine learning to a simplistic mindset of measurements and comparisons in our endeavour for a better education system.

We do seem fated to chase the phantom again; the new government is not much better than the Howard government in its pursuit of the measurable — whatever can be crunched in a computer is the limit of reality, it seems.

Look, people; I’m retired. Fatalistically, I will just let them go on their preset course reinventing the wheel. At the end of some period — five, ten years — they will wake up to discover that little has changed and certainly not much has improved.

I have said my piece before.

Comments Off on Measuring the quality of education not as simple as it seems – Letters – Opinion

Posted by on August 14, 2008 in Australia, Australia and Australian, education, exams and assessment, future schooling, Kevin Rudd, teaching


Revealed: Telstra’s secret plan to bust unions – National –

I’m sure some will say Mark Davis is not observing standards of journalistic objectivity in this story.

TELSTRA has devised a secret union-busting strategy to save $50 million in labour costs over the next three years – just enough to pay the chief executive, Sol Trujillo, and his senior executive “amigos” for one year.

Confidential Telstra documents obtained by the Herald show the company is gearing up to put non-union enterprise agreements to its staff in coming weeks, targeting business units with low unionisation rates.

The documents – prepared to brief Telstra’s group managing directors – also reveal it has a strike “mitigation” plan to use non-union employees and outside contractors if staff take industrial action.

They reveal that even while the company was negotiating with unions for a collective agreement in May and July, it had already drawn up detailed plans in February to bypass them and deal directly with its 32,000strong workforce…

I would say “Congratulations! Thanks for exposing these bastards yet again…”

There will come a time, not long hence, when Aussies will deeply regret this generation of imported business “talent” with its total disregard for our values and traditions.

Will the Rudd government stick it up them?

Sadly, I somehow doubt it…

Comments Off on Revealed: Telstra’s secret plan to bust unions – National –

Posted by on August 14, 2008 in Australia, Australia and Australian, globalisation/corporations, Kevin Rudd, Political, politics